04 June 2007

More on Latin American and Caribbean radical Islam

For those of you coming late to the party, I started with this first post on a quick look at some of the strangeness in the JFK plot and then went on to do a run-down of the basic woes of the Caribbean and Latin America with respect to terrorism and such. And this post picks up as a continuation of that second post. So less rigorous first just to get an initial scope-out and then the rundown of which this is a continuation.

Now where did I leave off?

Ah, yes, with Suriname, criminal Shaheed "Roger" Khan, also known as "Short Man," and the fact that Suriname and Guyana are 'safe havens' for criminals and terrorists. This was just shortly after the US Government being a bit stunned that a series of raids it led for Columbia against FARC was wider in scope than they thought it actually was. And stammered about saying how the US knew far more about FARC and its interconnections to other terrorist organizations than the mere locals! Hey, I get *that* from the US Government, too, on how well they spend my tax dollars...

So, before I wander back up to Trinidad and the radical groups there, it is time to take out the scissors to the idea that FARC is all out there, on its own, unconnected to anyone. To do that I will use the cluebat that just keeps on swinging - Ralf Mutschke, Interpol's Assistant Director, Criminal Intelligence Directorate and his 13 DEC 2000 written testimony presented to the Judiciary Subcommittee on Crime, looking at the spread of oranized crime from the Balkans, Russia and Eastern Europe:

Strategic Alliances between Crime Groups: the Colombian Nexus

The strategies devised by Colombian drug cartels merit a discussion in further detail. Over the years, these criminal entities have formed numerous alliances with other criminal groups in order to extend the scope of their illicit business. Their rational, and, incidentally, highly successful strategic decision making has led to providing them with a more global reach. The presence of terrorist groups in the area explains the obvious link between drugs and the arms trade in that region.

Generally speaking, the formation of alliances can be viewed as a response by a particular firm or company to overcome its own limitations. With the emergence of global markets, alliances are becoming a necessity for almost any business. Each firm has something that the other needs or wants, such as knowledge of a certain market or an established distribution network. Drug cartels, although an illegitimate business, are forming alliances with other organized criminal groups around the world to extend their operations and conquer new markets.

In order to smuggle their illicit products into the U.S., Colombian drug cartels began forming alliances with Mexican groups, who have a well-developed smuggling infrastructure for transporting drugs across the vast border with the United States. As Mexicans began to charge more for their services, Colombians established relationships with various Dominican, Jamaican, Puerto Rican, and African-American groups which act as smugglers and retailers for Colombian wholesale cocaine. Colombians have also formed an alliance with some of the Nigerian drug trafficking groups based on product exchange. In the early 1990s, Nigerian groups supplied heroin to Colombian drug traffickers in exchange for cocaine. Colombians were able to develop their own heroin market, while Nigerians started selling cocaine in Western Europe. During the late 1980s and early 1990s, an important alliance was formed between Colombian drug cartels and the Sicilian Mafia. Since the cocaine market in the U.S. was saturated, and because cocaine could be sold with higher profit margins in Europe, Colombians wanted to enter the European drug market. The Cosa Nostra’s well established heroin network was easily applicable to cocaine. In addition, the Sicilians had an excellent knowledge of European conditions and were able to neutralize law enforcement officials through bribery and corruption more effectively than the Colombians. From the Sicilian perspective, the alliance with Colombians was an opportunity to regain part of the market that had been lost to Chinese heroin traffickers. In recent years, South American drug cartels have been forming alliances with East European/Russian Organized Crime Groups in order to support and diversify their operations. East European groups have offered drug cartels access to sophisticated weapons that were previously not available. Helicopters, surface-to-air missiles, rocket-propelled grenades, and even submarines are on the drug cartels’ "shopping list." The East European groups provided new drug markets in Russia, the former Soviet Republics, and Eastern Europe, while consumption was decreasing in the U.S. In 1993, Russian police intercepted a ton of South American cocaine which had been shipped to St. Petersburg by one Russian crime syndicate working with a Colombian drug cartel. In another example, a Russian crime leader was arrested in January 1997 in Miami by U.S. agents for the exportation of cocaine from Ecuador to St. Petersburg (Russia) and then to the United States. In exchange for these services, drug cartels pay for transactions with high quality cocaine. East European/Russian crime syndicates and corrupt military officers are supplying sophisticated weapons to Colombian rebels in exchange for huge shipments of cocaine. Although the Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia (FARC) receives most of the arms, some of them are distributed to Hezbollah factions.

The financing of the two main terrorist organizations operating in Colombia, namely the FARC and the National Liberation Army (ELN), originates from several sources, with the most important one being the drug trafficking. A "tax system" ran by FARC collects $20 USD for each kilo of base cocaine produced, $30 USD for each kilo of crystal, and $2,500 USD for each use of a landing strip. Approximately 61% of FARC's operational area is also an area for cultivation and production of cocaine. The guerrilla members also protect the laboratories belonging to the narco-traffickers and this protection is provided in exchange for financial compensation. The largest amount, approximately $515 million dollars, was raised by Colombia's oldest guerrilla organization, FARC. The smaller National Liberation Army earned approximately $380 million dollars. These groups raised approximately $910 million dollars from abductions, extortion and drug trafficking in 1997. In the last four years, these groups’ earnings soared by 130%, which surpasses the combined incomes of Colombia's seven largest firms. Since 1996, the UNHCR estimates that more than 800,000 people have been displaced in Colombia as a result of guerrilla warfare. In an attempt to negotiate peace with guerrilla groups, the Colombian government granted the ELN a demilitarized zone in the northeastern provinces of Antioquia and Bolivar in April 2000. This is the second guerrilla safe-zone created in Colombia. The FARC’s own demilitarized zone, which lies in the jungles in the south, was created in 1998.

In the South American context, it is also worthwhile to mention Peru and Argentina. Like Colombia, Peru is combating guerrilla groups in the Andean jungles. The main guerrilla group is the "Sendero Luminoso" (Shining Path), led by Oscar Ramirez, also known as "Comrade Feliciano." In order to finance their operations and terrorist attacks, they often resort to drug production and smuggling. In May 1997, a joint action by the Peruvian military and police resulted in the capture of several leaders of the Shining Path. The Shining Path operates in the Apurimac valley, the second largest coca growing area in Amazonia. The increasing poverty in the region allows the guerrilla group to recruit young people between the ages of 14 and 18 and enlarge the scope of their activities. The rebels suffered a setback in their operations, however, when one of their leader, Oscar Ramirez Durand, was arrested in 1999.

It appears that Argentina is becoming a major money laundering center for organized criminal groups from Colombia and Mexico, and recently there appears to be activity from various East European/Russian organized crime groups. Since Argentina does not yet have an anti-laundering body, the total amount laundered annually is not known. According to a report by the International Monetary Fund (IMF), an estimated $6 billion dollars are laundered in Argentine banks each year. According to the Argentine federal police, approximately $5 billion came from Paraguay to be laundered in 1998. Allegedly, the money is usually channeled "through front companies in Uruguay, then through banks in the Caribbean, and finally to Europe and the United States".

Finally, the area called the "Triple Border", where Argentina, Brazil, and Paraguay meet is known for arms trafficking, vehicle theft, counterfeit currency, forged documents, as well as for being a refuge for Latin American, Lebanese, Russian, Chinese, and other criminal and terrorist organizations. It is not clear if the Hezbollah figures among these terrorist groups, but Islamic fundamentalists are suspected of having committed two terrorist attacks in Argentina : in 1992, a car bomb destroyed the Israeli embassy building in Buenos Aires and in 1994 another car bomb attack was directed against the "Mutual Association". These investigations are still ongoing and Interpol channels have been used for the exchange of information in the framework of these cases. To provide an idea of the scope of criminal activity in this area, a former President of the Brazilian Central Bank stated in 1999, that approximately $18 million USD are laundered daily in the banking agencies of the city of Foz de Iguazu (Brazil), a city which is located in this region.

The main smuggling routes to Europe originate in Brazil, Ecuador, and Venezuela. Cocaine is concealed in containers and shipped to Rotterdam (The Netherlands), Barcelona (Spain), Genoa (Italy), and the ports of some Baltic states. In addition, small boats transport cocaine from South America to Spain, where drugs are transferred aboard Spanish fishing boats. Lastly, an air route exists between West Africa and Europe. However, Spain continues to dominate as the main entrance point for Colombian drugs into Europe. In 1998, more than 31% of all cocaine seizures in Europe occurred in Spain. On August 2, 1999, the Spanish authorities seized ten metric tons of Colombian cocaine on a Russian-owned ship southwest of the Canary Islands. This shipment was the largest cocaine seizure carried out by European police. In addition, 200 kilograms of heroin were confiscated.

What appears to be the "forecast" for South America? In the northern tier - Colombia, Venezuela, Ecuador, Bolivia, and Peru - drug trafficking will continue to dominate along with insurgence of the guerrilla groups. The abundance of drugs and oil in the region, as well as guerrilla activities, is a dangerous mixture for political stability.
This amount of traffic in narcotics and other goods means there is a ripe opportunity for terrorist organizations to get their very own steady flow of funds via control of a portion of the traffic. Hezbollah, indeed, has been fingered for being in the region and the backers of Islamic terrorism in Argentina, Brazil and Panama. This is further backed up by the 2004 trial that I have referenced before from ttgapers citing a Trinidad Express article:

U.S. on Jamaat trail - Muslimeen member gives evidence about group's gun, drug-running operations
Sunday, August 15, 2004
- 03:05 PM

[..]

The John Doe witness is said to have told US authorities of a Muslimeen connection to a terrorist cell in Karachi, Pakistan, and of criminal jobs assigned to him by the Muslimeen hierarchy, including gun smuggling, drug trafficking and the payment of laundered funds to key members of the Mucurapo Road organisation.

He told of being directed to rendezvous with a key lieutenant in Brooklyn, New York, and of the latter providing him with false US Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS) documents and a social security card.

According to US sources, John Doe also testified about a key lieutenant of the Muslimeen supplying him with smuggled cocaine which he, in turn, sold to dealers in Connecticut. He is said to have returned almost all of the proceeds of the drug sale to his Muslimeen contact in the US and other high-ranking members of the group, keeping only a small fraction to cover his expenses.

The John Doe witness, who is said to have had some involvement in the May 30, 2001 failed attempt to smuggle a shipment of machine guns and assault rifles into this country, told US investigators of a Muslimeen plan to take possession of some of the weapons for the group's private use. He is also reported to have been privy to discussions relating to a Muslimeen plan to sell the rest of the weapons to the underworld. Transcripts of taped telephone conversations show a key Muslimeen official detailing plans to sell the AK-47 rifles in Trinidad for US$4,000 apiece.

Small, who has challenged legal efforts to extradite him to the US to stand trial on gun-running charges, was identified by co-conspirator in the aborted arms deal, Keith Andre Glaude, as the consignee to the shipment of 60 AK-47s and Mac-10 machine pistols with silencers, which was intercepted en route to Trinidad by US undercover agents in Fort Lauderdale.

Glaude, a former close associate of Small and another T&T national resident in the US, told investigators of the Muslimeen plan to ship the weapons cache to Trinidad concealed in a shipment of hollowed out furniture.

US agents, who lost track of the guns used in the 1990 uprising, report that the planned method of transportation for the arms cache in 2001 was almost a blueprint of the one used for the April 1990 shipment, which had its origins in Broward County and involved weapons concealed inside a stack of hollowed out plywood.

The guns used in the attempted coup were readily traced to international gun-runner and Muslim prayer leader Louis Haneef who collected them in a two-month buying spree during October and November of 1989. The money to buy the guns had been washed through BCCI, the Luxembourgh-based bank linked to drug smuggling, money laundering, Mid-East terrorism and covert CIA operations.

US authorities following Haneef's paper trail found US$18,000 worth of Bank of Bahrain-issued US Visa travellers cheques signed by Bakr and deposited in Haneef's bank account. Each cheque was good for US$1,000. Both the 1990 and the 2001 weapons shipments involved the use of a storage facility in Ft Lauderdale.

Since their 1992 release from prison on treason and murder charges, 48 members of the 114 original coup-makers, including Bakr, have been charged with a series of offences ranging from murder, through attempted murder and conspiracy to murder, to kidnapping, extortion, narcotics trafficking, armed robbery and possession of arms and ammunition.

Several of their members, including Paul Julien aka Abdul Qadir, have been linked to a series of bloody murders, among them the June 22, 1995 assassination of former Attorney General Selwyn Richardson.

Lawmen found fingerprints and other evidence linking Qadir, a Libyan-trained bomb specialist, to the Richardson murder. Qadir and Curtis Felix, aka Kedar, were reportedly brought in on a $200,000 contract by notorious crime figure Imran Ali to kill the former NAR minister for an unnamed client.

Richardson took six bullets at point blank range in the driveway of his Cascade home. Four days later, Qadir, who was being sought by the police in connection with the Richardson murder, was discovered slumped over the steering wheel of a green Mazda 929, registration PAX 4283, on the shoulder of the Solomon Hochoy Highway. The car was registered to Annisa Abu Bakr, one of Bakr's four wives. Qadir had been shot through the head, execution-style.
Yes, an individual gets into the US, gets false documents, smuggles cocain and uses the proceeds to get a compatriot to buy guns to smuggle back to Trinidad. Lovely how that works, isn't it? And this brings us back to Trinidad and Jamaat al-Muslimeen (JaM). Now as I have already been *over* them a bit, lets start branching out to their offshoots! You can't seem to get a group of religious extremists centering around a charismatic figure then, suddenly, you get others disagreeing with the figure and setting up their *own* even more extreme group.


Waajihatul Islaamiyyah (WI)

And just *why*, praytell, should we pay attention to this lot?

To answer that lets take a look at a bit found at a trinidad news forum on the leader of WI:

LOCAL police officers have seized several computer files from Umar Abdullah related to the activities of his organisation, Waajihatul Islaamiyyah (The Islamic Front) and its connections with several radical international Muslim groups.

Abdullah, a Princes Town-based fundamentalist Muslim, has been identified as the man being sought by US and British intelligence in connection with reported threats to American and British interests in Trinidad and Tobago.

Two months ago, he was held at a routine police roadblock in Rio Claro and several computer files and documents were found in his car.

The Express learned that the files were seized and Abdullah was interrogated by two Special Branch police officers. The files reportedly contained information on the United States, Israel and Britain and several articles written by Abdullah condemning these countries and advocating military action against them by Muslims.

Abdullah was reportedly taken from the Rio Claro Police Station by Special Branch officers to an internet cafe where he was ordered to download the information from the computer onto a diskette.

However, the Express understands that several key documents relating to the links between Waajihatul Islaamiyyah and international Muslim groups, possibly including Al Qaeda, Hamas, Jihad and Jama Islaamiyyah, were deleted before it could be downloaded onto the diskette.

Following the incident, Abdullah was charged with driving the car with false licence plates. He was subsequently fined for the offence.

FBI, CIA and British SAS agents are currently here investigating reports about plans to attack US and British interests in this country. Abdullah's organisation is suspected as the group behind the plans.

U.S. Embassy officials said yesterday they had "no comment" to make on the matter, while British High Commission's public relations officer, Phillip Everest, said the High Commission was in "touch with local security authorities". He would not comment further on the matter.

[..]

Senior police officials said yesterday Abdullah is a "well known fundamentalist" and confirmed that he is under constant surveillance as he "falls under the category of people who the police like to know about".

Abdullah's organisation openly supports Osama Bin Laden, Al Qaeda, the Taliban and a Jihad (Holy War) against the US and its allies. Through its monthly newsletter the group has made several calls for the establishment of an Islamic State in Trinidad and Tobago.

Yesterday Police Commissioner Hilton Guy said statements made by Abdullah about setting up an Islamic state were not enough to justify a sedition charge against him.

Abdullah's two houses, one at Chaguanas and the other at Princes Town, have been raided several times by police in search of arms and ammunition.
Yes, a follower of radical Islam trying to set up an Islamic State in Trinidad & Tobago (TT), just like the Taliban had in Afghanistan. So this fellow, Umar Abdullah (aka Omar Abdullah), seems to have some basic counter-intelligence capability and does his best to erase direct contacts while putting out more generalized support for al Qaeda and bin Laden. His words are more than just bluster, however, as over at the Oil & Gas Journal Newsletter - December 23, 2002 - volume 100, issue 52, we get this little number:

Government Developments
TRINIDAD AND TOBAGO'S security forces are on high alert following threats from an Islamic fundamentalist group to American and British energy interests in the Caribbean twin-island nation.

Reports out of the country's capital say its security forces have unearthed a plan by a group called Waajihatul Islaamiyyah (Islamic Front), led by Umar Abdullah, to attack US and British interests in Trinidad and Tobago. It is believed that the group has links with Al Qaeda. Officers from the UK's Secret Service along with the US Central Intelligence Agency and the US Federal Bureau of Investigation are on the island investigating the matter.

Firms from both the US and UK have invested billions of dollars in the Caribbean nation, most of which is in the energy sector. Numerous major oil and gas companies operate there, and it is a key country particularly for BP PLC and BG PLC.

It is understood that Trinidad and Tobago's intelligence officers intercepted a cellular telephone conversation in which Abdullah was heard planning to strike American interests on Dec. 22. Apart from energy interests, he allegedly discussed an attack on the US embassy in Port of Spain.

Frank Diaz, head of Trinidad's Special Branch, the security arm responsible for intelligence gathering, said that authorities have been following Abdullah for 3 years. Abdullah is known to US authorities who have assembled a dossier on his organizations.

Meanwhile, Prime Minister Patrick Manning, who also chairs his country's National Security Council, has refused to talk about the matter, saying he does not discuss national security matters publicly.

Trinidad and Tobago is a key supplier of natural gas to the US, particularly New England.
That is not a natural gas pipeline, but LNG transport ships. LNG is Liquified Natural Gas.

As in: under pressure until liquefied.

As in: floating bomb that is already a fuel-air explosive.

To see why *that* is a threat we head on over to the Institute for Analysis on Global Security and their Energy Security document of 15 NOV 2004:

Radical Islam and LNG in Trinidad and Tobago

Over the past several years, maritime attacks have become more violent, more frequent and clearly more organized. It is believed that militant groups, particularly in South East Asia, are practicing hijacking ships for their possible use as weapons. Of all types of vessels oil and chemical tankers are perhaps the most attractive targets for terrorists. These vessels are manned by smaller crews and loaded with volatile substances that could potentially cause significant damage. According to the International Maritime Bureau (IMB) attacks against tankers are growing at an alarming rate.

While all eyes are placed on the area surrounding the Malacca Straits, the world oil bottleneck, and on the Indonesian coast off Aceh, very little attention is placed on the U.S. underbelly of the Caribbean and the softer targets in the region closest to America's back yard: Trinidad, Venezuela and the Bahamas. These Caribbean countries are among the short list of natural gas producing countries and liquefied natural gas (LNG) and liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) exporters. Trinidad and Tobago alone account for 80% (1st quarter 2004) of all U.S. LNG imports, up from 68% in 2002. Therefore, any incident involving an LNG tanker along the Caribbean routes could harm not only U.S. energy security but also the economies of the Caribbean islands, affecting tourism and other industries.

LNG and Tanker Terrorism

U.S. Department of Energy figures paint a bleak picture for U.S. dependence on imported energy in the coming decades. Existing well heads in the U.S. are being depleted while demand for natural gas is expected to rise 2% a year. Imports from Canada, whose own energy demand is increasing, are projected to pick up some of the burden. But Canada's gas demand is growing faster than expected, also due to the gas intensive process of converting tar sands to crude oil, and thus its ability to export gas to the U.S. is being diminished. The U.S. will therefore be required to import more of its gas in LNG form from Nigeria, Sao Tome, Trinidad, Venezuela and the Persian Gulf. Today 2% of total gas usage in the U.S. is derived from LNG. By 2010 this figure is likely to grow to 10%.

LNG terminals and tankers present potential targets for terrorists. In the pre-9/11 world LNG tankers were considered among the safest ships at sea. These tankers are still as safe as is possible for a vessel of this nature today. But this statement is only valid if one pre-supposes that terrorists do not want an easily attainable weapon of mass destruction. The potential for mass casualty maritime suicide terrorism has changed our perceptions of safety at sea especially when it comes to lean crewed LNG tankers and other PCG (Petro/chemical/gas) and ships. With maritime terrorists currently combing the world for ways to make their message reach as wide an audience as possible, LNG tankers could be their perfect mass casualty weapon.

Islamic fundamentalism in Trinidad and Tobago

Trinidad and Tobago is a beautiful country in the Southern part of the Caribbean. It is in fact the southernmost of the Caribbean islands and the last island before Venezuela. It is one of the most affluent of the Caribbean islands with, for several years, the highest foreign direct investment per capita in the entire western hemisphere except for Canada. The home of tourism, steel band, calypso and carnival is unfortunately also the home of one of the first attempts at violently establishing a modern Islamic extremist state in the region after the attempted Islamic coup in July 1990. 15% of the island's population is Muslim.

The group responsible, Jama'at al Muslimeen under the control of Imam Yasin Abu Bakr, is alive and thriving in Trinidad. Congressional testimony of Major General Gary D. Speer, Acting Commander in Chief U.S. Southern Command to the House Appropriations Committee on International Relations, Subcommittee on Foreign Operations in April 2002 stated: "The recent bombing outside the U.S Embassy in Peru preceding President Bush's visit is indicative that other domestic terrorist groups pose threats to the United States elsewhere in the hemisphere. These include, but are not limited to, the Sendero Luminoso (Shining Path) and Tupac Amaru Revolutionary Movement (MRTA) in Peru and the Jama'at al Muslimeen (JAM) in Trinidad and Tobago."

Other groups active on the island are Waajihatul Islaamiyyah (The Islamic Front) and the Jamaat al Murabiteen. The Waajihatul Islaamiyyah group openly supports Osama Bin Laden, al Qaeda and Jemmah Islamiyyah, the organization behind the Bali beachfront bombing that killed close to 200 people. It has issued statements that it intends to set up an Islamic state and described itself as a revolutionary ideological movement. Their press releases include the following statements: "With our weapons we are going reach you. We will reach you where you sleep, we will reach you where you take your baths, we will reach you where you take your meals and have your drinks, and even a glass of water you hold in your hand to drink may not be safe." It added: "Don't for one second think you will be victorious. You feel you fight and kill us but you only fight shadows cast by the Qur'an and the teachings of the Prophet Muhammad. Your faith is in your hands-choose how it ends."

There have been other leads back to Trinidad as part of the global crackdown on terrorism. In March 2003, federal investigators announced publicly that they were searching for Adnan El'Shukri-Jumah, an American man named by a top al Qaeda operative as a trained terrorist. El'Shukri-Jumah had returned home to visit relatives in Georgetown during Ramadan 2001. He was traced to Trinidad and Canada but was lost enroute. The Sun-Sentinel reported that investigators were following up leads that El'Shukri-Jumah's father, Gulshair El'Shukri-Jumah, taught at the Darul Uloom Institute and Islamic Training Centre in Pembroke Pines, U.S. and suspicion turned to the Darul Uloom in Cunupia, Trinidad a 45-minute drive from Trinidad's capital, Port-of-Spain. The two schools shared the same name and the connections between El'Shukri-Jumah and the arrested al Qaeda operative led investigators to examine the likelihood them being part of a network for training and financing terrorists. Investigations into the connections were inconclusive.

On September 19, 2001 a man with ties to the Jamaat alleged to be linked to bin Laden pleaded guilty in a Fort Lauderdale, Florida, federal court to unlawful possession of a machine gun. Insight Magazine reported "Federal officials say that Keith Andre Gaude, who was detained in a U.S. Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms (ATF) sting operation, came to Florida to buy as many as 60 AK-47 assault rifles and 10 MAC-10 submachine guns with silencers."

In October 2002, Trinidad immigrant Shueyb Mossa Jokhan was sentenced to "nearly five years in federal prison for a terrorist bombing plot," according to the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel. The report said that Jokhan pleaded guilty to "conspiring to bomb electrical transformers and the Israeli Consulate in Miami." The plan reportedly was "hatched in a Florida mosque" and involved a Pakistani immigrant who recruited Jokhan for the attack.

In December 2002, Insight Magazine found further evidence that al Qaeda and two other Middle East terrorist groups had allegedly established operations and leading a holy war against U.S. and British interests from Trinidad and Tobago. "Umar Abdullah is "leading a group called the Islamic Front," believed to be "smuggling AK-47s, Tech-9s and Glocks" into the island country. It is believed that Abdullah may have fought in Afghanistan against the Soviet Union during the 1980s, and operates "in solidarity with al Qaeda and the Taliban" and is "maintaining relations with [the Palestinian terrorist groups] Hamas and Islamic Jihad." All these incidents indicate a growing presence of Islamist fundamentalism in the part of the world where America's LNG comes from. Without question there is concern that the significant presence of U.S. and British petroleum companies in the oil-rich nation provide easy pickings for terrorists. Local opinion is that this is the reason U.S. and British counterterrorism experts are on the island.
Why, 19 SEPT 2001 is just after 9/11... coincidence? But even behind that, notice the use of Piracy to support terrorism and Piracy is an Act of War. And LNG tankers are a one-stop shop for the WMD-wannabe terrorist group: gaseous fuel kept in liquid state that is highly under pressure that, when ruptured, can disperse the contents and explode, sucking in oxygen as the explosion expands and sending out a forceful and long lasting shockwave as it does so. FAE bombs, in the military parlance, are known as "Daisy Cutters". Or a similar Massive Ordinance Air Burst bomb (MOAB)... although I do believe an LNG tanker would make that seem like a matchhead.

Now the linkages from Umar Abdullah become a bit clearer and even more radical: bin Laden, al Qaeda, Taliban, Muslim Brotherhood/Hamas/Islamic Jihad. It is Muslim Brotherhood/Hamas/IJ ties that I looked at when Rep. Steny Hoyer recently went to Egypt to meet up with some members of MB there, apparently looking for 'moderate terrorists'. Globalsecurity gives us a view of Hamas and its funding, which I will excerpt:
HAMAS receives funding from Palestinian expatriates, Iran, and private benefactors in Saudi Arabia and other moderate Arab states. Some fundraising and propaganda activities take place in Western Europe and North America. As of 2003 US intelligence sources estimated that the militant Palestinian group Hamas had an annual budget of 50 million dollars, raising much of that money through its reputation as a charity. Despite its notoriety worldwide as a terrorist group, many Palestinians see Hamas as a charitable organization that builds schools and hospitals and steps in where the Palestinian Authority has failed.

The Hamas organization is also operating in European countries and the United States, mainly among the Palestinian population, by conducting fundraising (through charity associations and foundations - Dawa activity). Some of the funds received are channeled to finance terrorist activity in Israel, and other monies are intended for the funding of Hamas civilian activity. The United States is seeking to bankrupt Hamas by undermining its reputation as a charity.

[..]

It is not possible to separate the Dawa activities conducted for humanitarian purposes from the direct and indirect funding of terrorism: All the monies flow into a common fund, and are then channeled to the relevant activities, in accordance with needs and in coordination with the functions of the organization in the territories and abroad. The monies are transferred using the following means: bank transfers, moneychangers, private money services, unofficial networks for the transfer of funds and "unsuspecting" assistants. Thus, in view of the great difficulty in tracing the source of the money, its address and the motives behind the transfer of funds, it is essential that a strict and vigilant approach be adopted towards the entire fundraising network, operating within the framework of Dawa activity.
Hamas is a distributed funding enterprise, concentrated in the Palestinian territories, but radiating outwards as an all source funding organization. Here I must again emphasize that the irregular, person-to-person and informal banking and money exchange networks tend to thwart the sophisticated banking networks due to the nature and type of activity that is seen by them. I went over that in this post, but suffice it to say that the Arab/Middle Eastern hawala system has its various counterparts for other populations, in particular the Peso Exchange System. Utilizing small value transfers over a period of time or dispersed amongst multiple accounts and yet all having quick access to them, allows for such transactions to get lost in the noise of the regular banking system and not show up *at all* in the informal ones.

Even worse is the ability of such organizations in the Caribbean to smuggle not only narcotics, but terrorists into the US. In testimony given to the House of Representatives on 25 JAN 2000, Steve Emerson cited this as yet another means to get into the US:
In addition to false documents, alien terrorists and their support operatives frequently engage in immigration benefit fraud. One of the most glaring examples would be asylum fraud. All one has to do is show up at a US port of entry, even without documents, utter the two magic words "political asylum," have any moderately truthful sounding story and one is likely to be processed in - at least temporarily. The tightening of the asylum process over the past couple of years has helped - but, be a fraudulent asylum claimant showing up at a very busy Point of Entry such as JFK Airport or Miami International Airport - and you are likely to remain in detention for only a short time before you are paroled out to (hopefully) appear at a later hearing! If a name (real or false) does not appear in any of the lookout systems and the applicant merely has an alleged "friend" to stay with in the US, then parole from detention is most likely. Of course, it goes without saying, terrorist aliens so released seldom show up again - and the INS, because of serious manpower shortages and conflicting priorities, rarely pursues such absconders. Of course, any number of other immigration fraud schemes abound - marriage fraud, other familial relation fraud, naturalization fraud, work visa fraud (H-1 and L-1 and "E" status - as used by Islamic Jihad officials Ramadan Abdullah Shallah and Bashir Nafi), investor fraud and religious worker fraud.

Smuggling of alien terrorist operatives - apart from the noted utilization of false documents: alien terrorists use established alien smuggling pipelines across both the US-Mexico and US-Canada border. Maritime smuggling along the coasts, particularly via the Caribbean as well as East and West Coast seaports, occurs. How easy can it be for a terrorist operative to bribe his/her way onto a freighter destined to a busy US seaport, and simply be hidden aboard the vessel until Customs and INS have done their routine inspections, then to simply disembark the vessel?

The issue of classified evidence in immigration proceedings is now under assault by editorialists in the media and from some members of Congress. What they forget is that these proceedings are administrative in nature - not criminal - and such evidence, in spite of all the recent hoopla, is only rarely and very selectively utilized. Deportation proceedings ultimately result in a person being removed from the US - not sentenced to prison (as in criminal proceedings) - even though aliens may be detained while those proceedings go forward. As such, it should be remembered that aliens detained hold their own cell keys -all they have to is simply agree to be deported and they can be free - just not in the US. Moreover, Congress itself approved of the Classified Information Procedures Act, in which classified information can be introduced in criminal trials without releasing this information to the defendant.

Unfortunately, too many senior INS managers do not recognize the critically important role INS enforcement branches, particularly the Investigations Division, can and should play in the counter-terrorism and national security arena. These are officials at both the HQ and field levels. INS has but a small contingent of agents dedicated to this work - and, often those do not receive the recognition and support from higher management they should. INS should have at least a hundred field agents assigned to these missions - at least the same it has assigned to Organized Crime Drug Task Force efforts - but in fact INS has less than half that assigned to counter-terrorist efforts in the field. I have been told that it is not unusual for very senior INS officials - especially at headquarters (who should know otherwise), when the topic of counter-terrorism arises in senior staff meetings, to state, "that's the FBI's responsibility" and "what does INS have to do with that"! Certain key, senior INS managers fail to even understand and recognize the very statutes within the Immigration and Nationality Act they are charged with enforcing!
That is why "Comprehensive Immigration Reform" will not work: the Government Bureaucracy has no interest nor PAY in enforcing the laws. But do note that individuals that get *into* the US using the narcotics route do not go through any port of entry, so individuals like those that show up from Islamic radical groups in the Caribbean have multiple ways to get into the US: standard port of entry if their group is not on the State or Treasury list or they are not on either, personally, human smuggling routes through Mexico and Canada, and narcotics smuggling via light aircraft and ships. That is why groups like JaM and WI are a threat: their connection to false passports and documents (or even *real ones*) allow them to shift individuals into the US 'under the radar'.

I have previously looked at the testimony of Janice L. Kephart before the House Judiciary Committee on 08 JUN 2006, and will now look at one individual who basically utilized this informal system to commit terrorism in the US:

John Lee Mohammad in Antigua and Baruba. John Lee Mohammed, the U.S. citizen responsible for 10 fatal shootings and 3 other near fatal shootings during a terrorist-style spree in the autumn of 2002, had financially survived prior to coming to the United States by selling forged U.S.-accepted travel documents—driver’s licenses and birth certificates.

Muhammed brought Lee Boyd Malvo and his three children into the United States under false names, and in at least 20 incidents forged or stole identities for clients, secured air travel, and provided documents in order to secure their travel to the United States. In some cases, he charged as much as $3,000. He forged documents for Lee Boyd Malvo’s mother when she deserted her son, but when he was not paid, Malvo essentially was kept as collateral.

With simply a birth certificate or baptismal record and a driver’s license, Mohammed’s clients, covered by the Western Hemisphere Exception for travelers from North, South or Central America or the Caribbean (but for Cuba), could easily pose as American citizens or citizens of one of the covered nations, and enter the United States.

After the Task Force created by the Attorney General of Antigua and Baruba released its Final Report in December 2002, the GAO released two 2003 studies about the ease of being admitted into the United States with counterfeit birth certificates and driver’s licenses from Canada, Mexico, Jamaica and the Bahamas, this Committee held a hearing on the topic.

The ease of fraudulent entry using something other than U.S. passports for those claiming U.S. citizenship was not limited to Muhammed and his clients.
The idea that radical Islamic groups could do this is not only well within the realm of comprehension, but, due to the lax nature of many Nations for records establishment, extremely easy to do. This now gets us back to the other, major individual cited by the FBI and wanted for questioning in regards to the JFK plot who had *also* gotten into the US for *years* on fraudulent documents: Adnan El-Shukrijumah.

Ms. Kephart spends quite some time on him and what she had to say is worth a gander, to say the least:
Born in Saudi Arabia, Adnan El-Shukrijumah, aka “Jafar the Pilot,” has spent 15 years in the United States (mostly in South Florida), speaks fluent English, and has been employed as a teacher.

El-Shukrijumah trained with Jose Padilla to partner in the dirty bomb plot, helicopter plots, and the New York and New Jersey financial infrastructure plots discovered in the summer of 2004. A Department of Homeland Security document quoted in Newsweek states that “KSM has identified Adnan el-Shukrijumah, a Saudi born permanent U.S. resident alien, as an operative with standing permission to attack targets in the United States that had been previously approved by Osama Bin Ladin.”

FBI Director Robert Mueller called him “a trained operative who poses an operational threat to the United States” who the FBI considers to be armed and dangerous. In late 2000 or early 2001, El-Shukrijumah was under investigation for his relationship to Imran Mandhai, convicted in Florida of conspiring to bomb a National Guard armory, power stations, Jewish businesses, and Mount Rushmore prior to 9/11. Mandhai was associated with Hakki Cemal Aksoy, convicted in 2002 for firearms violations and asylum fraud and in whose apartment bomb making manuals and notes were found.

El-Shukrijumah had previously applied for naturalization, but the INS interior enforcement office in Miami noticed that the application was fraudulent. The INS agents working the case met with the U.S. Attorney’s Office in Miami, and even discussed seeking a search warrant for El-Shukrijumah’s residence. Without further information linking El-Shukrijumah to terrorist activity, the matter was dropped.

As an LPR, El-Shukrijumah easily traveled to and from attended training camps in Afghanistan, where he was most likely schooled by Ramzi Binalshibh, famous for his role as emissary between KSM and 9/11 ring leader Mohamad Atta. El-Shukrijumah is a skilled bomb maker and a Florida trained pilot, and authorities have found a document that ties him (via one of his aliases) to the Oklahoma flight school where Zacarias Moussaoui trained. He may have been friendly with Atta as well, as I describe an immigration officer’s witnessing of receiving a request for help with travel documents in May 2001 from El-Shukrijumah on behalf of Atta and likely another 9/11 pilot in 9/11 and Terrorist Travel. According to Attorney General John Ashcroft, El-Shukrijumah “scouted sites across America that might be vulnerable to terrorist attack.” In addition to surveilling high-profile targets in New York’s financial district, El-Shukrijumah surveilled the Panama Canal.

Back in the United States, he was also involved in an aborted plot with Jose Padilla to blow up apartment buildings in the United States. He was also likely Padilla’s first partner in the dirty bomb plot, but differences between them ended the joint venture. There are also reports that El-Shukrijumah attempted to procure radioactive material from McMaster University in Hamilton, Ontario. In March 2004, El-Shukrijumah attended a terrorist summit in Pakistan and met with a number of key al Qaeda members, including Abu Issa Al-Hindi, Mohammed Naeem Noor Khan, and Mohammed Babar. IN past months he has been spotted in Mexico. He reportedly met with members of the Mara Salvatrucha gang (known as MS-13) in Honduras, although Interpol denies the existence of evidence of such a meeting. In September 2004, the Aviation and Security Association reported, “An alert airline crewmember saw and then confronted a suspicious acting person at Kansai International Airport in Japan. El Shukrijumah was this suspicious person.” However, law enforcement was not notified.

Reporting indicates that since El-Shukrijumah fled the United States after 9/11, he has tried to get back into the United States using various passports. He has a Guyanese passport, but may also hold passports from Saudi Arabia, Canada, and Trinidad. However, unless authorities made a decision to permit Shukrijumah his freedom for law enforcement or intelligence reasons, or know that he did manage to enter the United States on one of these passports undetected and law enforcement knows about it, I do not place much credence in these reports.
"Jafar the Pilot", who's father lived in Florida according to a report cited by Caribepundit. Having passports from TT, Guyana, Saudi Arabia, Canada. And here is some of what his friend Imran Mandai was up to, as seen by James W. Ziglar in testimony to the National Commission on Terrorist Attacks Upon The United States on 26 JAN 2004:
In 2001, information was developed that Imran Mandhai, a Pakistani national and lawful permanent resident of the United States, was plotting to destroy electrical facilities in South Florida by placing bombs at transformer and electrical substation sites. Additional plot discussions involved whether to target the Israeli Consulate in Miami, a military reserve facility, or a hospital and other locales in Tallahassee, Mandhai was arrested in February 2002 for administrative violations relating to sabotage and terrorist activities after admission to the United States. Evidence included a videotape of Mandhai identifying and handling shoulder-fired rocket launchers, AK-47s and AR-15s. He and a co-conspirator were charged with conspiracy to destroy property by fire and explosives, and solicitation to commit a crime of violence.
Yes, I am sure just a terrorist 'wannabe' that was doing the logistical casework and scouting out sites to attack and exsamining how to actually use and utilize weapons of war. One who put forth that attacking a Nation's power grid is important before invasion and is also disruptive in and of itself. More worrying is the citation of trying to get cooperation with the international gang Mara Salvatrucha (MS-13). The MIPT Terror Knowledge Base gives an overview of them here, and points out the endemic nature of the gang and its widespread population making it difficult if not impossible to eradicate. And as a Landed Permanent Resident of the US, having actual and official US documents and supplementing them with other documents allows him pretty wide travel as seen with the incident in Japan.

So with that side trip to a globe trotting terrorist from al Qaeda, lets now look a bit more at what else there is in the Caribbean to deal with. Coming from a Jamestown article on the JaM trial comes this quick stop on the other groups around TT on 09 MAR 2006:
A key aspect of radical Islam in Trinidad is the Afro-Trinidadian character of organizations such as the Jamaat al-Muslimeen and its numerous offshoots, which include the Wajihatul Islamiyyah (Islamic Front), Jamaat al-Murabiteen (The Almoravids), and Jammat al-Islami al-Karibi (Caribbean Islamic Group).

[..]

Significantly, the above-mentioned groups are led by former protégés of Abu Bakr who parted ways or were expelled from his Jamaat. Abu Bakr's prosecution is unlikely to lead to the end of the Jamaat al-Muslimeen, or the radical current among Afro-Trinidadian Muslim groups in Trinidad more generally, at least in the near-term.

[..]

Al-Qaeda in Trinidad?

Trinidadian and international sources often point to the presence of al-Qaeda and other international terrorist organizations in Trinidad and Tobago with the potential to threaten U.S. interests in the Caribbean Basin and Latin America. Due to its lucrative energy reserves and its strategic placement in the Caribbean off the coast of Venezuela, and Muslim minority, part of which has a history of resorting to political violence, many observers believe that Trinidad represents an attractive target for groups such as al-Qaeda. Al-Qaeda's documented successes recruiting Muslim converts elsewhere, including Afro-Caribbean converts, is also a point of concern.

The tendency of groups such as Jamaat al-Muslimeen to resort to violence against the state and its rivals and to engage in criminal activities has also led some to worry about the influence of radicals such as Abu Bakr and their potential to collaborate with international terrorist organizations with broader agendas.

In reality, the brand of Islamist radicalism found in Trinidad has so far remained a strictly Trinidadian phenomenon stemming from a narrow fringe of the Muslim community, essentially an outgrowth of the fractured body politic that characterizes Trinidadian politics. The ethnic divide between Trinidad's African and East Indian communities that transcends sectarian affiliation, in addition to the rivalry between the tiny Afro-Trinidadian Muslim minority and Trinidad's influential East Indian Muslim community in particular, goes far in explaining the trajectory of the movement.

Given this background, there is little evidence to suggest that groups such as Jamaat al-Muslimeen or its offshoots in Trinidad represent ideal allies for al-Qaeda, although their documented role in extensive crime should be of concern.
Thus the number of groups is relatively high, given the small area of TT, but they do represent a minority of a minority and when they splinter off they become minor factional groups. As seen with WI, that does not mean they cannot pose a threat. While there are very few, beyond Abu Bakr, that have deep ties with the Middle Eastern/Arab radical Islamic groups, that does not mean that such groups are not interested in TT or the Caribbean basin in general. The ability to get ready access to Latin American Nations, hop borders to escape police, and also utilize Piratical tactics does demonstrate a long-term concern for the US.

Now for some updates on the individuals involved in the JFK plot!

From 03 JUN 2007 at Bloomberg:
Russell Defreitas, a 63-year-old former Evergreen Airlines cargo worker, was arrested on June 1 in Brooklyn, said New York City Police Commissioner Raymond Kelly. Defreitas is a U.S. citizen and native of Guyana, a former British colony in South America.

Defreitas, who was alleged to have used his knowledge of the airport to describe its security measures, was arraigned before a Federal magistrate and ordered held until a bail hearing on June 6, said his attorney, Andrew Carter Jr. The lawyer declined further comment.

Held in Trinidad

Abdul Kadir, a former member of Guyana's parliament and Kareem Ibrahim, a man from Trinidad, are being held in Trinidad and will be arraigned there tomorrow, said Assistant Brooklyn U.S. Attorney Greg Andres.

U.S. law enforcement officials didn't release the ages of Kadir and Ibrahim or say if they had been assigned lawyers for their court appearance. Abdul Nur, a citizen of Guyana, is at large in Trinidad or Guyana, authorities said.
Still at large? Well, that is the normal course of affairs in the region, isn't it?

From Trinidad & Tobago Express we get this excerpt to add into the mix on 03 JUN 2007:
The two men arrested in Trinidad on Friday, Kareem Ibrahim and Abdul Kadir, are both imams of Shia mosques here and in Guyana respectively.

A third man, a Guyanese known as Abdul Nur, also a Shia, is on the run and believed to be hiding here.

The United States has issued arrest warrants for all three.

Sources from the Police Special Branch say they are in the "process of trying to determine whether Ibrahim has links to radical Shia groups in the Middle East based on information passed on to us the FBI."

FBI agents are in Trinidad investigating this and other aspects of the case involving Ibrahim and Kadir.

Local police say they were informed by their US counterparts that unlike previous terror plans that involved Sunni Muslims with Al Qaeda links it is the first time that a plot of this kind involving Shias has been uncovered.
Anyone keeping track of Islamic terrorism will have noted that the actual sect or branch involved does not, necessarily, determine which group is backing another group. Iran's backing of al Qaeda in Iraq and Lebanon, as examples, show that they are more than willing to fund those they disagree with on a limited basis.

From Barbados Nation News on 03 JUN 2007 there is a little to add:
Kadir was arrested around 11 a.m. on Friday at Piarco Airport trying to board a flight to Venezuela, while Ibrahim was held around the same time at his mosque in Tacarigua.

Kadir was heading to Iran via Venezuela for an Islamic conference.

Up to yesterday, both men were being questioned by the Special Branch and FBI officers.

The FBI also visited the Jamaat al Muslimeen yesterday as Ibrahim is said to have visited the mosque on "occasion". Ibrahim is not a member of the Jamaat nor affiliated to the Mosque.

Paul confirmed that there was no information linking the Jamaat to the plot.

Ibrahim, 56, is the imam of one of the two leading Shia mosques in Trinidad. He is a father of five.
Which is pretty much it on the updating part. I am sure that more will come to light over time, as a number of these individuals are of interest as is any connections between them and more established terrorist and/or organized crime syndicates.

Still no confirmation of things from the first post and digging isn't getting more. So time to let this simmer, for a bit, although there are *plenty* of outward links that should be tracked down.

03 June 2007

Radical Islam in the Caribbean

Seeing the terror plot to hit JFK Airport and Queens, it looks to be time to expand the scorecard of radical Islam in the Western Hemisphere! So, using this threat as a start, lets jump head first into the coups, splits and diversity of the Islamic communities of our Neighbors to the South. And as there is really no good place to start with this, we might as well start with the one currently implicated:

Jamaat al-Muslimeen (JaM)
This fun group of fanatics is headed up by Yasin Abu Bakr, born Lennox Phillips in 1942 he migrated in 1968 to Canada, converted to Islam, and returned to Trinidad & Tobago (TT) in 1970. (From Westernresistance) Of the groups, this one is one of the oldest and one of the more radical as it actually staged a 5 day coup in 1990 to overthrow the government in TT and had been combining North American 'Black Power' ideas with that of Islamic radicalism during the late 1970's and formed into something close to what it is today. JaM, for all of its violence is a minority of a minority inside TT, so the idea of it being a 'liberating' group is a bit far-fetched. During the coup one of Bakr's able lieutenants, Bilal Abdullah, had stated (Paper for Florida International University by Ken I. Boodhoo, 1992 ):

"What we are seeking to do," he asserted, "is to Islamize the society."
From what can be seen they were supplied with the weapons to stage this from an operative in Florida. From the Brady Center comes this lowdown on the actual arming of the coup (pdf here, p. 13/36):
The Jamaat Al Muslimeen had previously done business with Florida gun dealers, and these sellers were willing to meet their ample needs. In 1990, the Muslimeen – armed with weapons purchased at Florida gun stores and shows – tried to topple the government in Trinidad and Tobago. More than 100 rebels set off a car bomb and then stormed into the legislature spraying bullets from the Florida-bought guns. They took over Trinidad and Tobago Television to announce they had seized control. Two dozen people were killed and hundreds wounded during six days of chaos.

The Muslimeen’s gun runner in 1990 was Louis Haneef, a resident of Pompano Beach. Of the 135 weapons used in the coup against the government of Trinidad and Tobago, 105 assault rifles were provided by Haneef. He had told Florida gun shop owners that he needed the weapons for his business, the “All American Gun Club.”38

As was the case with firearms trafficker Donald Fiessinger in Illinois, Haneef was able to accumulate a cache of guns because there are no federal laws limiting the number of purchases by an individual. Haneef was a familiar figure at gun stores and gun shows all over south Florida. “Flashing wads of $100 bills, Haneef bought dozens of assault rifles, shotguns, carbines and pistols.”39

The Muslimeen failed in its coup attempt and eventually surrendered, but the group remains active and has been linked to bomb threats and other insurgent activities in Trinidad.
Now, far be it from me to point out that radical Islamic groups getting automatic weapons and into bombings are *not* the way to dissuade me from purchasing a gun. Just the opposite, really. One does wonder where they get such strange ideas.

The TT Parliament also cites Louis Haneef in this plot during its proceedings (pdf here, p. 25) in 1992. This would not be the only time that JaM came around looking to arm up on the cheap! As I looked at in the post just previous, JaM would be trying to do so again with a much larger cast of characters to get things going:

The Sunday Express was told that the former Muslimeen official, now in a US Witness Protection Programme, is the John Doe witness who testified before a federal grand jury hearing into three counts of gun-running charges against Lance Small aka Olive Enyahooma-El, a high-ranking member of the Muslimeen and a key Bakr lieutenant at TTT during the 1990 uprising.

This newspaper understands that the man, identified by US authorities only as "John Doe", disappeared from the Trinidad scene about a year ago after the Director of Public Prosecutions, Geoffrey Henderson, issued a warrant for his arrest on murder charges.

Reached yesterday, Henderson said he had no comment on the matter.

The John Doe witness is said to have told US authorities of a Muslimeen connection to a terrorist cell in Karachi, Pakistan, and of criminal jobs assigned to him by the Muslimeen hierarchy, including gun smuggling, drug trafficking and the payment of laundered funds to key members of the Mucurapo Road organisation.
You really do have to love these aliases and new names folks get themselves. But I can see where he is coming from because if your name is Clive Lancelot Small then going for a flashy aka like Olive Enyahooma-El has *got* to be a step up in the world. Still, fingering a connection to Pakistan does bring up the question of which radical Islamic group they are affiliated with as there are a few of them in Pakistan.

To do *that* we can also look at that previous post and this from Nazim Baksh, a CBC reporter, who had been reviewing the Islam that he knew and loved as it was corrupted by outsiders in TT, and one of the people he met in his travels trying to understand just *what* had taken over Islam:
In the summer of 1990, three months after I joined the CBC, one hundred very angry Muslim men staged a coup in the twin-island Caribbean state of Trinidad and Tobago. Using an arsenal of illegal weapons they seized control of Parliament, took the Prime Minister hostage and shot him the leg for good measure. They did make him sign a document pardoning them for doing this. The name of this radical group was Jamaat Al-Muslimeen, which translates as “The Muslim Group.”

I knew these characters, had met some of them before, including their leader, Yasin Abu Bakr. I would later run into him while on assignment in the Sudan. There he was sipping tea at the Hilton in Khartoum and complaining to me about how unfair Canadian officials were for not allowing him to visit his family in Toronto. It didn’t take me long to realize that there was a world of difference between the Jamaat’s Islam and mine.
Yes, Yasin Abu Bakr in Sudan. Lovely place where al Qaeda was operating at the time, before the final Taliban takeover in Afghanistan and things getting too hot to stay in Sudan. Basically at that time as a radical Muslim in Sudan you are either with Muslim Brotherhood or al Qaeda. This tie is strengthened by the direct testimony of Janice L. Kephart suring Hearing before the House Committee on the Judiciary Subcommittee on Immigration, Border Security, and Claims on 08 JUN 2006:
There were also reports prior and subsequent to 9/11 U.S.-sought Adnan El- Shukrijumah was living in Trinidad near schools that share his last name. In addition, two men with ties to Trinidad have been arrested in the United States. Keith Andre Gaude, a Jammat linked to bin Ladin, pled guilty on September 19, 2001 to unlawful possession of a machine gun. BATF officials stated he had come to Florida to “buy as many as 60 AK-47 assault rifles and 10 MAC-10 submachine guns with silencers."
She does bring up Shukrijumah, who I will get to farther on, but here the placing of Keith Gaude as the Jammat link to bin Laden is the confirmatory of the Baksh report. The next guy she talks about is a demonstration of the type of terror attack that is customary in other parts of the world:
In 2002, Trinidad native and U.S. naturalized citizen Shueyb Mossa Jokhan was sentenced to 58 months in federal prison for a “jihad” mission that included bombing an electrical power station and a National Guard Armory. According to the FBI, “these attacks were then to be followed by a list of demands to be placed on the United States government and other governments around the world. The defendants also sought to acquire AK-47 type assault weapons for their jihad training and operations, and sought to obtain the release from custody of an individual described as a "mujahedin" fighter committed to jihad.”
We get a bit more on this individual from IAGS Energy Security, more on that later:
In October 2002, Trinidad immigrant Shueyb Mossa Jokhan was sentenced to "nearly five years in federal prison for a terrorist bombing plot," according to the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel. The report said that Jokhan pleaded guilty to "conspiring to bomb electrical transformers and the Israeli Consulate in Miami." The plan reportedly was "hatched in a Florida mosque" and involved a Pakistani immigrant who recruited Jokhan for the attack.
Say, if Trinidad is such a nice place, how come it incubates such nasty, radical Islamists?

Like 'Buffy'.

Who is 'Buffy', you ask? This 'Buffy' has a long list of aliases, from what I have been able to determine, and is one of those violent sorts that not only does his best to stay one step out of custody but also gets incompetent prosecutors and ends up skating on technicalities. He is
David ‘Buffy’ Millard
aka Edmund DeFreitas
aka Mustapha Abdullah Muhammad (source:
Guyana Chronicle)
aka "Phantom Killers" (from a
web discussion board) - hard to tell if he is one of them or a contact
From Guyana Chronicle and the previous Western Resistance blog we can see he has been involved in: Conspiracy to commit murder of Zaki Aubaidah (Bakr's son-in-law who wanted to leave JaM), Salim ‘Small Slim' Rasheed, Adel Ghany on 04 JUN 2003 and the murder of Jillia Bowen. He was charged along with Mohammed Hassin, aka Joseph Aboud and Brent ‘Big Brent' Miller (source Kaieteur News) for the murder of Jillia Bowen.

Previous Millard had been in the US in NY and Miami in 1980 and graduated from St. Mary's College and was either deported from the US or, by his account, fled from "the underworld" because he was wanted by a few folks. He almost immediately joined up with JaM and formed a close relationship with Bakr. Just before the murders he had been working for the People's National Movement and gotten a Ministerial job doling out funds from the Unemployment Relief Program which, by all accounts, was not run well and highly corrupt at the time. Of course just a few months later he fled the country for Guyana, which has been a haven for criminals on the lam in that region of the world.

In 2005 a series of bombings and killings in Trinidad would also be linked to JaM, starting with 12 JUL 2005 and ending on 14 OCT 2005. On 02 JAN 2006 a Libyan trained member of JaM,
Andre "Baldhead" Bynoe, aka Rasheed Abdul Karim, was killed most likely due to theft of goods at the job he was at.... or, since he was part of the coup, it could be 15 year delayed payback. On 17 FEB 2006 18-year old Zaffir Ali was killed and he was the son of Imam Hassan Ali who is a prominent JaM member. That was most likely due to local gangland violence than anything else. Later that year on 22 AUG 2006 a member who had left JaM, Roger "Black Roger" Bridgeman, was found shot and killed in his car which had been ambushed.

Libya... why, yes, lets hit the Jamestown article on Al-Qaeda's inroads to the Caribbean:
U.S. and Trinidadian authorities have kept a close eye on the Jammat’s activities since the 9/11 attacks, but there is no hard evidence tying the group to international terrorism, let alone al-Qaeda. However, Abu Bakr did maintain links with Libya’s Muammar Qadhafi in the 1980s and 90s and considers him a close friend to this day. The Jammat reportedly received funds through Libya’s World Islamic Call Society (WICS) to finance the construction of its main mosque, schools, and a medical center, but there is no evidence linking Tripoli with the failed 1990 coup attempt. Abu Bakr’s most recent publicized links with controversial international figures include Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez.
There you have one well connected radical Islamist! al Qaeda, Kadaffy and Chavez! Oh, the article is a couple of years old, so it missed the trial info above to do the al Qaeda tie-in. Now I can already hear the cries of 'Gaddafi is secular and Chavez has no ties to Islam'!

Really?

From Globalsecurity on Gadhafi:
The revolutionary government gave repeated evidence of its desire to establish Libya as a leader of the Islamic world. Moreover, Qadhafi's efforts to create an Arab nation through political union with other Arab states were also based on a desire to create a great Islamic nation. Indeed, Qadhafi drew little distinction between the two.

The government took a leading role in supporting Islamic institutions and in worldwide proselytizing on behalf of Islam. The Jihad Fund, supported by a payroll tax, was established in 1970 to aid the Palestinians in their struggle with Israel. The Faculty of Islamic Studies and Arabic at the University of Benghazi was charged with training Muslim intellectual leaders for the entire Islamic world, and the Islamic Mission Society used public funds for the construction and repair of mosques and Islamic educational centers in cities as widely separated as Vienna and Bangkok. The Islamic Call Society (Ad Dawah) was organized with government support to propagate Islam abroad, particularly throughout Africa, and to provide funds to Muslims everywhere.

Qadhafi has been forthright in his belief in the perfection of Islam and his desire to propagate it. His commitment to the open propagation of Islam, among other reasons, has caused him to oppose the Muslim Brotherhood, an Egyptian-based fundamentalist movement that has used clandestine and sometimes subversive means to spread Islam and to eliminate Western influences. Although the brotherhood's activities in Libya were banned in the mid-1980s, it was present in the country but maintained a low profile. In 1983 a member of the brotherhood was executed in Tripoli, and in 1986 a group of brotherhood adherents was arrested after the murder of a high-ranking political official in Benghazi. Qadhafi has challenged the brotherhood to establish itself openly in non-Muslim countries and has promised its leaders that, if it does, he will support its activities.
Not only *involved* but pushing his own BRAND of Islam against the Muslim Brotherhood. I bet you thought he was just ordinarily cuckoo.... then there is Hugo Chavez and for that we head back to Ms. Kephart a bit later in the testimony to Congress:
Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez is well known for his violent dictatorship-like leadership, affiliations with Cuba (where his troops are sent for training), and his support of FARC in Columbia (enhancing chaos and violence in that country). In 2001, he signed cooperation agreements with Libya, Iraq, and Iran. On 9/12/01, Chavez ordered government workers to burn U.S. flags in the streets to celebrate the attacks of 9/11.

What is less known is that in January 2003, Chavez’s former personal pilot, having come to the United States after an attempt on his life and claiming political asylum, stated that immediately following 9/11, Chavez ordered the pilot (Venezuelan Air Force Major Juan Diaz Castillo) to "to organize, coordinate, and execute a covert operation consisting of delivering financial resources, specifically $1 million, to [Afghanistan's] Taliban government. The purpose of the “donation” was to “assist the Al Qaeda terrorist organization," while, "making it appear as if humanitarian aid were being extended to the Afghan people."

According to Castillo’s account, one million dollars was delivered to Afghanistan via the Venezuelan ambassador in India. The Taliban acknowledged receiving $100,000 in "humanitarian aid." Castillo said the remaining $900,000 went to al Qaeda. Chavez never answered the allegations, despite public demands to do so.

According to the National Review, Castillo’s allegations are consistent with remarks made by the former head of Venezuela’s border security, who stated that while in that position he was pressured to permit anonymous travel of Middle East and other terrorists passing through Venezuela and to deceive U.S. terrorism investigators. "I quit my job when I got tired of doing dirty work for Chavez with the Cubans looking over my shoulder," he said.
Can't get more supportive of Islam than sending aid to help the Taliban and al Qaeda against the US and putting out the WELCOME mat to Islamic terrorists to help filter them into the US.

Now, since FARC has been mentioned, it is fair game here, in the Latin American part of the Transnational Terror network and there is a doozy from Columbia for those folks who think that a couple of nice documents should do it for verifying folks, and the Jamestown folks are the ones with a great article on this:
Colombian authorities claim to have dismantled an extensive counterfeit passport ring in January 2006 that allegedly supplied an unknown number of Pakistanis, Egyptians, Jordanians, Iraqis, and others purported to be working with al-Qaeda with Colombian, Portuguese, German, and Spanish citizenship, enabling them to travel freely in the United States and Europe. Bogota also mentioned that the network had ties to Hamas militants (al-Hayat, January 28; Caracol Radio, January 26).

In contrast, U.S. Justice Department and Department of Homeland Security officials expressed surprise at Bogota's announcement while emphatically disputing its claim, alleging that they had no knowledge of known links between the document forgery operation and any brand of Islamist terrorism, let alone al-Qaeda. Instead, they acknowledged that the sting operation involved Colombians posing as members of the Fuerzas Armadas Revolucionarias de Colombia (FARC) or Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia, the country's largest and most powerful rebel group, interested in purchasing forged documents and possibly even weapons (U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement Report, January 27). Washington classifies FARC as an international terrorist organization.

Since the September 11 attacks, Washington fears that radical Islamist terrorist organizations such as al-Qaeda may exploit Latin America's porous borders, endemic corruption, and weak institutions to gain a foothold in the region in order to infiltrate U.S. territory or to stage attacks against vital U.S. interests in the region. Many observers believe that Colombia, a strong ally of Washington, with its vibrant narcotics trade, ongoing insurgencies, robust energy reserves, and proximity to the Panama Canal and other vital shipping lanes, represents an ideal target.

FARC's extensive involvement in the drug business and its documented ties to regional and international drug cartels and organized crime, coupled with the control it wields over large swathes of Colombian territory out of Bogota's reach, is of particular concern. In a worst case scenario, Washington worries that al-Qaeda may cultivate alliances of convenience with organizations such as FARC or others involved in the drug trade in order to raise finances or procure armaments. At the same time, it is important to note that there is no credible evidence pointing to this kind of formal cooperation. At the very least, however, terrorist organizations can exploit established money laundering and finance networks used by narcotics traffickers and organized crime syndicates in the region, especially the Black Market Peso Exchange (BMPE), to fund future operations (El Siglo, June 25, 2003).

It is against this background that Colombian and regional governments have played on U.S. concerns by moving to curry favor with the U.S. to further their own domestic agendas and international standing in the context of the Bush Administration's war on terrorism. In doing so, they often highlight the alleged threat of al-Qaeda or other brands of radical Islamist terrorism within their own borders.

Based on the evidence, this latest attempt by Bogota is a case in point in that it likely represents an effort to enhance its position in the eyes of Washington and the international community in its longstanding war with FARC guerillas. Since one of the alleged members of the smuggling ring, Jalal Saadat Moheisen, happened to be of Palestinian descent, it is likely that Colombia seized the opportunity to win political points in Washington by pointing to a possible link to Middle East terrorist networks.

What makes Colombia's bold claims especially interesting is that the sting operation was in fact led by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) officials and other investigators, who worked in concert with their Colombian counterparts in the Department of Administrative Security (DAS).

Normally, references to alleged al-Qaeda infiltration are enough to gain the attention and headlines governments in Latin America seek. For example, El Salvador, Nicaragua, and Honduras have pointed to alleged al-Qaeda links with the Maras street gangs that terrorize their cities. Mexican officials have hinted at al-Qaeda involvement with rebel indigenous groups in Chiapas. Trinidadian authorities have employed similar tactics when it comes to discrediting their own homegrown Islamist opposition centered in the Afro-Trinidadian Muslim community.

U.S. concern over the strong showing by Hamas in the recent Palestinian elections is likely responsible for Bogota's decision to include Hamas alongside al-Qaeda in its recent claims of radical Islamist involvement in the document forgery ring.
Ok, count all the various actors there! Some of it, to be sure, is probably overblown, but just how long HAS that ring been operating? Perhaps not operating a lot with al Qaeda, but can anyone say that it definitively *hasn't* in the past. Also I do need to remind folks that FARC tried to Assassinate a recent sitting President and is now looking to leverage *that* against the US Congress to get a break from having too much funding go to Colombia. And I go through the entire person to person setup of such things and how they work in this post, so I won't go into it here except to say it is a huge concern as it allows for distributed money laundering that is damned near untraceable.

And, speaking of organized crime, the Jamestown folks do a good look at that and terrorism in the Latin America with this article from which I will extract just a bit on Suriname:
Reports that Jamaat al-Fuqra (JF), an obscure Muslim group with branches in Pakistan and North America that has been linked to terrorism and crime, is making inroads into the Caribbean, especially among Afro-Caribbean Muslim converts and East Indian Muslims in nearby English-speaking Trinidad and Tobago and neighboring Guyana, raise concerns about Suriname (The Trinidad Guardian, April 8). Sheikh Mubarak Ali Shah Gilani, JF's founder and leader, is believed to have spearheaded the movement in Pakistan in the early 1980s. Gilani also heads the International Quranic Open University (IQOU), which is affiliated with the Muslims of the Americas (http://www.iqou-moa.org). JF has been implicated in a series of murders and bomb plots targeting religious and ideological rivals in the United States and Canada. In the United States, JF is comprised primarily of African-American Muslim converts. The group is best known for establishing a number of isolated rural communities across the United States for its members (Terrorism Monitor, August 10).

Organized Crime and Corruption

In June, Shaheed "Roger" Khan, also known as "Short Man," a Guyanese national of East Indian descent and reputed narcotics and arms kingpin wanted by U.S. authorities on an outstanding warrant for crimes committed while residing in the United States, was arrested in the Surinamese capital of Paramaribo; three Guyanese associates and eight Surinamese nationals were also apprehended. Khan is believed to have fled his native Guyana after being implicated in the theft of arms from the Guyanese armed forces. He is known locally as a key player in the drugs and arms trade between Guyana and Suriname. Both countries are experiencing an alarming increase in organized criminal and violent street gang activity (Guyana Chronicle, June 18).

Surinamese sources claim that Khan was planning to assassinate Surinamese government and judicial officials, including cabinet members (Guyana Chronicle, June 19). The sting operation that led to Khan's arrest yielded over 200 kilos of cocaine and an assortment of arms. Paramaribo expelled Khan to nearby Trinidad for entering the country illegally. Trinidad denied Khan entry into the country because he lacked valid travel documents. He was subsequently handed over to U.S. officials and is currently awaiting trial in a U.S. jail on drug trafficking charges (Caribbean Net News, June 19).

There is no evidence that implicates Khan in terrorism. Nevertheless, the relative ease in which Guyana's most wanted man fled to Suriname along with a cadre of trusted cohorts to continue his lucrative criminal enterprise underscores Suriname's vulnerability in the eyes of security officials. In fact, both Suriname and neighboring Guyana have served as sanctuaries for high-profile criminals on the run. David "Buffy" Millard, a member of Trinidad's Jamaat al-Muslimeen, was arrested in Guyana recently and extradited to his native Trinidad to face murder charges (Trinidad Guardian, May 6). In another case, Brazilian authorities implicated Surinamese security officials in an illicit arms trading network that allegedly smuggled weapons to criminal gangs in Brazil, including violent groups such as the Red Command and the First Capital Command. Both organizations are involved in a lucrative drug and arms trade based out of Brazil's impoverished favelas (urban slums) and prisons (Caribbean Net News, February 3).
Jamaat al-Fuqra, huh? This is getting to be old home week! My post on their outpost in Georgia, USA is here and lets just say that it is more than a bit worrying. And that gets us to the Tri-Border Area and another link back to JaM and all sorts of fun goodness!

We haven't even GOTTEN to the splinter groups of JaM yet! You can't have a radical Islamic group *alone*.... oh, no, it has to splinter into a couple of groups so they can all get riled up at each other, find different backers and affiliates and then start killing each other. But I will be kind and leave off here, because this is a boatload to digest. And the other players in the JFK plot haven't gotten their time in the spotlight.

02 June 2007

The JFK terror plot and the links outwards

H/t to Michelle Malkin and posting the capture of the JFK terror document!

What a lovely day this hasn't been with all sorts of weirdness showing up when you look at terrorists from the Caribbean basin. The basics you probably already know, but the quick rundown: A group of fine guys were hatching a plot to utilize one of the main fuel lines and reservoir systems for JFK airport to torch it, blow up the control tower and set a goodly part of Queens ablaze. Luckily it was still in the plotting stages, so that is not an immediate worry.

You can't have a plot without plotters and so we come to the list of those involved: Russell Defreitas, Abdul Nur, Kareem Ibrihim and Abdul Kadir.

Now, Abdul Kadir has been identified as an ex-Parliamentarian from Guyana and that fits with this listing from a pdf document of proceedings of their Parliament: Mr. Abdul Kadir, J.P., M.P. (Region No. 10 - Upper Demerara/Berbice). And as a public official he did get involved in a thing or three, and so we get this photo from the Linden Fund for an award presented to a student in his district:



Abdul Kadeer on the Left

What did we ever do without the internet? From that, however, things get... weird. What are the chances that there will be more than ONE Abdul Kadeer from Guyana? I mean the muslim population there is a small part of the overall population and that name is not so well distributed around the world.

The reason I ask is that there is one very interesting Abdul Hamid Kadir that I did run across.

In a Dept. of Justice case that he brought against Regal Dental Ceramics, from the San Francisco area. Why is this interesting? You see... well, the case does a good job on that, so let me just present the salient bit from page 2:

On October 4, 1993 Abdul Hamid Kadir, ("Complainant" or "Kadir"), acting pro se, filed a complaint against Regal Dental Ceramics, Inc., ("Respondent" or "Regal Dental"), a California corporation, with the Chief Administrative Hearing Officer ("CAHO") alleging that he was knowingly and intentionally fired because of his national origin and citizenship status in violation of § 102 of the Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986 ("IRCA"), 8 U.S.C. § 1324b, as amended.

More specially, the complaint alleges that Kadir was born in Guyana, South America, and became a United States naturalized citizen on March 15, 1988. Compl. at ¶¶ 3, 4 and 6. The complaint further alleges that he was employed by Respondent from October 21, 1991 to May 15, 1992 in the job of "fabrication of understructure of dental crowns/bridges."
Highlighting is mine. Does anyone remember that Amnesty deal from 1986? This is, also, 3 years after the Jamaat Muslimeen coup... but I am getting ahead of myself! We are getting into a vast and tangled web of connections so let us pick them up one at a time and see where they go to. And since I brought up al Qaeda.... have I done that yet? Ok, I haven't, so I will let the FBI do that, this from Michelle's site:

FBI agents feared but never confirmed the three men accused of plotting to attack John F. Kennedy International Airport in New York were linked to one of the most wanted al Qaeda leaders, Adnan Shukrijumah, known to have operated out of Guyana and Trinidad.
There, he gets to do the scut work and bring it up! Adnan Shukrijumah is a lovely piece of work, born from Saudi father and Guyanese mother and traipsing around the Caribbean and Latin America for some time working for al Qaeda. From a Jamestown article on Al-Qaeda's Inroads into the Caribbean we get this:
The potential threat of al-Qaeda using the Caribbean Basin as a base of operations came to the fore when allegations circulated that Adnan G. El-Shukrijumah, a known al-Qaeda operative, was reportedly spotted in Honduras in June 2004. Despite a lack of hard evidence, U.S. and regional security officials believe that Shukrijumah’s alleged presence in the region stemmed from an al-Qaeda plot to link up with Central American gangs such as Mara Salvatrucha (MS) and Mara 18th Street (M18). U.S. Panamanian officials reported that Shukrijumah was in Panama as early as April 2001, possibly surveying high-value targets such as the Panama Canal, after which it is alleged he visited several neighboring countries [1]. Trinidadian sources go a step further and tie Shukrijumah to the Darul Uloom, an Islamic institute in Trinidad, and claim he may have infiltrated Central America via Trinidad and Tobago with a Trinidadian, Guyanese, or Canadian passport [2].

[..]

U.S. and Trinidadian authorities have kept a close eye on the Jammat’s activities since the 9/11 attacks, but there is no hard evidence tying the group to international terrorism, let alone al-Qaeda. However, Abu Bakr did maintain links with Libya’s Muammar Qadhafi in the 1980s and 90s and considers him a close friend to this day. The Jammat reportedly received funds through Libya’s World Islamic Call Society (WICS) to finance the construction of its main mosque, schools, and a medical center, but there is no evidence linking Tripoli with the failed 1990 coup attempt. Abu Bakr’s most recent publicized links with controversial international figures include Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez.

[..]
There we have one man connecting al Qaeda with two other localized terrorist groups, and utilizing multiple passports to get around. One can't get around without good ID and here was a lovely source of same, from ttgapers 21 AUG 2004 citing the Toronto Star:

2 charged in passport forgeries in Guyana
Saturday, August 21, 2004 - 08:03 PM

GEORGETOWN, Guyana - A Canadian Embassy employee has been charged with fraud on suspicion of forging 12 passports. Guyanese authorities also arrested a man who is accused of using one of the fake passports.

Varsha Brijmohan, a 24-year-old Guyanese national, was suspended from her post earlier this week. She is accused of forging the Canadian passports while working as an assistant consular officer, said deputy police chief Henry Greene.

Anthony Correia, 23, was charged with fraud after an attempt was made to use one of the passports to buy a car. Both pleaded not guilty to the charges. Their trials begin Sept. 24.

It was the second scandal involving the Canadian Embassy in Guyana in recent years. In the early 1990s, the Canadian government moved its consular services for Guyana to Trinidad after discovering employees were selling visas.
Yes, just drop on by and BUY a real set of Canadian passports direct from the source. Drop on by any time and get your REAL IDs for cold, hard cash. That is obviously one way to get a Canadian passport, and I am sure Mr. Shukrijumah could get a good connection or two to score one. Maybe he could even get a good birth certificate or find a forger to make one for him, and get one instant Western Identity to then roam around the world, used as needed. Speaking of passports there is someone else that somehow got their hands on a Guyana passport, as reported over at Xignite (limited uses available on articles) when the Guyanese authorities uncover the true identity of a terror suspect:

THE Trinidad terrorist suspect nabbed in a Joint Services raid on a house south of Georgetown earlier this week, is not the man he claims to be, sources confirmed yesterday.

The Guyana Defence Force (GDF) Thursday [ 4 May] night announced that the man held in the raid in the continuing search for 30 AK-47 rifles and five pistols stolen from its Georgetown headquarters, had identified himself as Mustafa Abdullah Muhammad, also known as Edmund DeFreitas.

He has, however, now been identified as David Millard, well-known in Trinidad as 'Buffy', who fled from New York after a shooting incident and returned to Trinidad where he moved up the ranks of the radical Jamaat Al Muslimeen group led by coup leader Abu Yasin Bakr.

A top source yesterday said authorities are trying to find out how Millard found his way here and acquired a Guyana passport in the name of Edmund DeFreitas, recorded in the travel document as born in March 1960 at Bartica in Guyana.

[..]

But the Guyana Chronicle understands that Millard was not involved in the 1990 attempted coup.

At the time of the attempted coup, he was in New York, but fled sometime later as a result of a shooting incident. He returned to Trinidad and moved up the ranks of the Jamaat Al Muslimeen.

He never used his Christian name and everyone in Trinidad knew him as Buffy, this newspaper understands.

Trinidad reporters following the case yesterday said that when the Jamaat's number three man, Mark Guerra, was killed in March 2003, 'Buffy' assumed that position and was considered a right hand man of leader Abu Bakr.

On June 4, 2003, in his bedroom in Diego Martin, six miles west of Port-of-Spain, 'Buffy' allegedly met Bakr and two others to plan the murder of two expelled members of the Jamaat. There was a shooting incident that night outside of Port-of-Spain in which one of the two expelled members was shot, but an innocent woman was killed.

[..]
Now wait just a second! Edmund DeFreitas? We have a DEFREITAS on Michelle's site as the main author of this plot for the JFK bombing! And he is linked with that terror group I mentioned earlier. Fun, huh? And he was freed of charges, too, as witness Ummah News:

So, if the leader of the plot thats made to get you and me is THIS guy, then he is the one and the same 'Buffy'. Ok, we are now starting to get a feel for the level of corruption in the Caribbean and Latin America, aren't we? Awash in a sea of fake IDs or real IDs for sale, radical Islamic groups and just plain, old fashioned, regular terrorist groups. Not speaking of Mr. Kadir, which I wasn't, lets do another alias check and see what we get for him! From the very same ttgapers 15 AUG 2004 citing Trinidad Express :
U.S. on Jamaat trail - Muslimeen member gives evidence about group's gun, drug-running operations
Sunday, August 15, 2004 - 03:05 PM

[..]

The John Doe witness is said to have told US authorities of a Muslimeen connection to a terrorist cell in Karachi, Pakistan, and of criminal jobs assigned to him by the Muslimeen hierarchy, including gun smuggling, drug trafficking and the payment of laundered funds to key members of the Mucurapo Road organisation.

He told of being directed to rendezvous with a key lieutenant in Brooklyn, New York, and of the latter providing him with false US Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS) documents and a social security card.

According to US sources, John Doe also testified about a key lieutenant of the Muslimeen supplying him with smuggled cocaine which he, in turn, sold to dealers in Connecticut. He is said to have returned almost all of the proceeds of the drug sale to his Muslimeen contact in the US and other high-ranking members of the group, keeping only a small fraction to cover his expenses.

The John Doe witness, who is said to have had some involvement in the May 30, 2001 failed attempt to smuggle a shipment of machine guns and assault rifles into this country, told US investigators of a Muslimeen plan to take possession of some of the weapons for the group's private use. He is also reported to have been privy to discussions relating to a Muslimeen plan to sell the rest of the weapons to the underworld. Transcripts of taped telephone conversations show a key Muslimeen official detailing plans to sell the AK-47 rifles in Trinidad for US$4,000 apiece.

Small, who has challenged legal efforts to extradite him to the US to stand trial on gun-running charges, was identified by co-conspirator in the aborted arms deal, Keith Andre Glaude, as the consignee to the shipment of 60 AK-47s and Mac-10 machine pistols with silencers, which was intercepted en route to Trinidad by US undercover agents in Fort Lauderdale.

Glaude, a former close associate of Small and another T&T national resident in the US, told investigators of the Muslimeen plan to ship the weapons cache to Trinidad concealed in a shipment of hollowed out furniture.

US agents, who lost track of the guns used in the 1990 uprising, report that the planned method of transportation for the arms cache in 2001 was almost a blueprint of the one used for the April 1990 shipment, which had its origins in Broward County and involved weapons concealed inside a stack of hollowed out plywood.

The guns used in the attempted coup were readily traced to international gun-runner and Muslim prayer leader Louis Haneef who collected them in a two-month buying spree during October and November of 1989. The money to buy the guns had been washed through BCCI, the Luxembourgh-based bank linked to drug smuggling, money laundering, Mid-East terrorism and covert CIA operations.

US authorities following Haneef's paper trail found US$18,000 worth of Bank of Bahrain-issued US Visa travellers cheques signed by Bakr and deposited in Haneef's bank account. Each cheque was good for US$1,000. Both the 1990 and the 2001 weapons shipments involved the use of a storage facility in Ft Lauderdale.

Since their 1992 release from prison on treason and murder charges, 48 members of the 114 original coup-makers, including Bakr, have been charged with a series of offences ranging from murder, through attempted murder and conspiracy to murder, to kidnapping, extortion, narcotics trafficking, armed robbery and possession of arms and ammunition.

Several of their members, including Paul Julien aka Abdul Qadir, have been linked to a series of bloody murders, among them the June 22, 1995 assassination of former Attorney General Selwyn Richardson.

Lawmen found fingerprints and other evidence linking Qadir, a Libyan-trained bomb specialist, to the Richardson murder. Qadir and Curtis Felix, aka Kedar, were reportedly brought in on a $200,000 contract by notorious crime figure Imran Ali to kill the former NAR minister for an unnamed client.

Richardson took six bullets at point blank range in the driveway of his Cascade home. Four days later, Qadir, who was being sought by the police in connection with the Richardson murder, was discovered slumped over the steering wheel of a green Mazda 929, registration PAX 4283, on the shoulder of the Solomon Hochoy Highway. The car was registered to Annisa Abu Bakr, one of Bakr's four wives. Qadir had been shot through the head, execution-style.

[..]
Do the phonetic Islamic transposition tango and Kadir and Kedar makes the spelling of Gadaffi seem easy! Curtis Felix as Kadir? Damnifiknow! But now lets do the rundown of who was NOT involved in the JFK plot directly:

1) Jamaat Muslimeen - well, ok, possibly directly connected, but still not directly named as of this second.

2) Libya via their trained hit man Paul Julien/Abdul Qadir and from Abu Bakr's own association with Gaddafi.

3) Curtis Felix/Kedar? Or is he Kadir? If he is just another terrorist/criminal thug, then thats one thing...

4) Imran Ali - Notorious crime figure (I have always wanted to say that!).

5) BCCI - Bank of Crooks and Criminals International, one of the main money laundering banks before it was shut down by the UK.

6) Keith Andre Glaude. Who?

7) Louis Haneef - Muslim prayer leader and gun runner.

8) Unnamed contact in Brooklyn, NY. What? Brooklyn? That was mentioned at Michelle's site as having a meeting place between DeFreitas and unnamed contact.

9) Canada, for its easy passport sales division.

10) Hugo Chavez via Bakr. Can't seem to swing a dead cat around that region without hitting up Hugo for some flowers.

That is the scorecard so far, but only so far. Now time to get another man's personal review of his life and HIS meeting up with radical Islamic fundamentalists. For that we go to Nazim Baksh at the CBC:
[..]

In the summer of 1990, three months after I joined the CBC, one hundred very angry Muslim men staged a coup in the twin-island Caribbean state of Trinidad and Tobago. Using an arsenal of illegal weapons they seized control of Parliament, took the Prime Minister hostage and shot him the leg for good measure. They did make him sign a document pardoning them for doing this. The name of this radical group was Jamaat Al-Muslimeen, which translates as “The Muslim Group.”

I knew these characters, had met some of them before, including their leader, Yasin Abu Bakr. I would later run into him while on assignment in the Sudan. There he was sipping tea at the Hilton in Khartoum and complaining to me about how unfair Canadian officials were for not allowing him to visit his family in Toronto. It didn’t take me long to realize that there was a world of difference between the Jamaat’s Islam and mine.

Before I was over that story, Saddam Hussein invaded Kuwait in August 1990 and when the United States and its allies drew lines in the sand he invoked Quranic verses in a desperate attempt to gain support in the Muslim world. He didn’t get my support because I knew that he was quoting verses from the Quran that suited him, leaving aside what would condemn his actions.

Later that same year El-Sayed Nosair shot and killed Rabbi Meir Kahane in downtown Manhattan. It was a completely insane act, an act prohibited under Islamic law.

Nosair was portrayed as a crazed lone gunman who took the law into his own hands. The daily demonstrations outside the courthouse told a different story. I spoke with countless people, some of them friends and acquaintances in New York who had such strong sympathies with Nosair that they donated considerable amount of money for his defense.

Nosair troubled me so deeply that I did my own research and discovered that Muslims who migrate to countries such as the United States or Canada are required under Islamic law to obey the laws of these countries whether they like them or not. No disagreements on this among the fuqaha, the scholars of law. We are not allowed to do anything that will cause harm, physical or otherwise, to our fellow citizens. And if we don’t like the laws or institutions of these countries, we have a choice. But as long as we live here and we accept citizenship or landed status, we are in a contractual relationship with a sovereign state and that contract must be honored. This does not rule out legal protest or the freedom to voice our opinions or disagreements with certain policies.

In 1991, the RCMP arrested five Muslim men and charged them with conspiracy to bomb a Hindu temple in Richmond Ontario and an Indian theatre in Toronto’s little India. I was asked by my newsroom to track this story and I have to say that I was totally unprepared for what I would discover. To my surprise the group these men belonged to was involved in no less than 17 assassinations and fire-bombing in the United States in the 1980s. Trinidadian and Guyanese authorities fingered the group for two more assassinations.

In 1993, Feb. 26, in the last days of the month of Ramadan, a bomb exploded in an underground garage of the World Trade Center. In the days that followed, the FBI founded up dozens of Arab men, the same men who demonstrated in support of Nosair, men who prayed five times a day, fasted like I did in the month of Ramadan. Men who would insist on eating halal meat, grew their beards, had families, wives and children, much like my own.

I spent eight months gathering material for the making of the “Seeds of Terror,” a full-edition documentary aired by the CBC’s 5th Estate exactly a year after the bombing. I spent weeks in New York gathering information on the men implicated in that act of terror. I traveled to Sudan, Afghanistan, and Pakistan and came face to face with the terrifying faces of Islamic fundamentalists, men who talked tough and carried dangerous weapons to back it up.

And it dawned on me as clearly as the sun rises in the morning that while we may share a few things in common, they were not my people. They are intruders into my community, loud and obnoxious men devoid of love. Most of them have never read a single line of poetry from Mawlana Jalaluddin Rumi or Fariddin Attar. Their books are filled with chemical formulas, detailed map and bomb-making techniques.

They have staged an internal coup, hijacked and ruptured a 14-hundred years-old rich and textured tradition.

They are to Islam what Timothy McVeigh is to Christianity.

[..]
Why he is one of those rarest of species: A Moderate Muslim who speaks UP! But, beyond that, do you notice where he meets up with Bakr? In Sudan. At that time the home of: al Qaeda. A man who would overthrow the government of Trinidad & Tobago for a short period in terror central of the Sudan. Now the picture is becoming just a bit clearer, isn't it? No?

Ok, then lets try this name out of left field to start tying things up a bit on the aQ side: Walid El Hage. Frontline at PBS does a nice wrap up of his nefarious career and his part in the Meir Kahane assassination and 1993 WTC bombing support role. Who is he?

Osama bin Laden's personal secretary.

Lovely how an outside spectator can put in a nice piece to the larger puzzle and start to let one know that America has been 'cased' since the late 1980's by al Qaeda. And right around this same time we get this view from Ralf Mutschke, Interpol's Assistant Director, Criminal Intelligence Directorate in his 13 DEC 2000 written testimony presented to the Judiciary Subcommittee on Crime:
In order to smuggle their illicit products into the U.S., Colombian drug cartels began forming alliances with Mexican groups, who have a well-developed smuggling infrastructure for transporting drugs across the vast border with the United States. As Mexicans began to charge more for their services, Colombians established relationships with various Dominican, Jamaican, Puerto Rican, and African-American groups which act as smugglers and retailers for Colombian wholesale cocaine. Colombians have also formed an alliance with some of the Nigerian drug trafficking groups based on product exchange. In the early 1990s, Nigerian groups supplied heroin to Colombian drug traffickers in exchange for cocaine. Colombians were able to develop their own heroin market, while Nigerians started selling cocaine in Western Europe. During the late 1980s and early 1990s, an important alliance was formed between Colombian drug cartels and the Sicilian Mafia. Since the cocaine market in the U.S. was saturated, and because cocaine could be sold with higher profit margins in Europe, Colombians wanted to enter the European drug market. The Cosa Nostra’s well established heroin network was easily applicable to cocaine. In addition, the Sicilians had an excellent knowledge of European conditions and were able to neutralize law enforcement officials through bribery and corruption more effectively than the Colombians. From the Sicilian perspective, the alliance with Colombians was an opportunity to regain part of the market that had been lost to Chinese heroin traffickers. In recent years, South American drug cartels have been forming alliances with East European/Russian Organized Crime Groups in order to support and diversify their operations. East European groups have offered drug cartels access to sophisticated weapons that were previously not available. Helicopters, surface-to-air missiles, rocket-propelled grenades, and even submarines are on the drug cartels’ "shopping list." The East European groups provided new drug markets in Russia, the former Soviet Republics, and Eastern Europe, while consumption was decreasing in the U.S. In 1993, Russian police intercepted a ton of South American cocaine which had been shipped to St. Petersburg by one Russian crime syndicate working with a Colombian drug cartel. In another example, a Russian crime leader was arrested in January 1997 in Miami by U.S. agents for the exportation of cocaine from Ecuador to St. Petersburg (Russia) and then to the United States. In exchange for these services, drug cartels pay for transactions with high quality cocaine. East European/Russian crime syndicates and corrupt military officers are supplying sophisticated weapons to Colombian rebels in exchange for huge shipments of cocaine. Although the Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia (FARC) receives most of the arms, some of them are distributed to Hezbollah factions.
From the late 1980's onwards a coming together of organized crime and transnational terrorism. And what do we see that John Doe doing? Yes, smuggling cocaine...

More on this later. But think of gun runners, crime bosses, Hezbollah, and the Tri Border Area.

This is *not* a pretty picture.

01 June 2007

Theoretical security and the more, unpleasant, reality

Well, with the inanity of the Illegal Alien Amnesty Bill comes those who do put forth that it would actually *help* find and stop terrorists! A h/t to Curt at Flopping Aces for pointing out this post at Big Lizards by Dafydd ab Hugh responding to Hugh Hewitt's worries about terrorists getting a parole Z-Visa and being here legally in: Where's Walid? In this exercise we will posit that the bill actually passes! From there we will pass into the theoretical projection and see where it leads us. So lets take it from the mid-way point:

Suppose the bill passes, and a bunch of illegal immigrants apply for Parole Cards (the provisional Z visas -- at least, that's what Sen. Jon Kyl, R-AZ, 92%, calls them). Hugh's worry is that among all the Gonzaleses and Ramirezes and Garcias will be hidden a few Mohammeds and Zarqawis... or even a Padilla or two.

Hugh is terrified that these terrorists could also apply for Parole Cards, and then be able to move around the country, get work, and even exit and reenter the United States at will. Of course, they can do that today... but Hugh seems to believe that they're more likely to be caught and deported today, with no bill, than they would be next year with a bill and Z visas and Parole Cards. (I have no idea what current mechanism for capturing and deporting them Hugh sees; it certainly eludes my sight.)

Let's carefully break down what it means to exit and reenter the country and to work: The border-crosser must show a passport and a SmartVisa. Specifically, he must swipe the card through a reader; this necessarily creates a record of leaving and reentering. Too, moving from place to place within the U.S. and working also creates a phosphor trail. But so what? How does that help capture terrorists?

Enter the CIA's old computer connection-tracking program, Total Information Awareness. Congress got hysterical in 2003, defunding it -- or so they thought; but it's widely believed still to be in existence, just shifted under the umbrella of black-ops programs and funded by secret accounts.
Ah, such a lovely trust of the Federal procurement system and the ability of the CIA and other organizations to create an interconnect database system that will do its very own dot connections and spew out the leads and such as it goes.

Now, here is the deal with this bill: it requires scanty evidence to apply for a Z-Visa and the automatic grant of such. Let us see about this in section 601 of the online markup page at NZ Bear's site. For once I will try and spare the dear reader of large amounts of quoted text and cite important page and refernces! I am sure there will still be lots of quoted text, however.

Starting with Section 601 on p. 260 we get who, being here illegally, can apply. Now far be it from me to point out the conundrum of being here illegally being a violation of not only National Law but any number of Treaties as I already did that with this post and this post. Yes someone applying must now demonstrate that they were here illegally for at *least* 180 days prior to 01 JAN 2007 or for 90 continuous days before that date! And what do they need to get in? Here is 601 (2)(g)(2)(A):

(A) In General.--The application form shall request such information as the Secretary deems necessary and appropriate, including but not limited to, information concerning the alien's physical and mental health; complete criminal history, including all arrests and dispositions; gang membership, renunciation of gang affiliation; immigration history; employment history; and claims to United States citizenship.
And in (3) is fingerprints added to that. All of this fully documented and cross-checked! And in 601(2)(h)(1):

(1) IN GENERAL- An alien who files an application for Z nonimmigrant status shall, upon submission of any evidence required under paragraphs (f) and (g) and after the Secretary has conducted appropriate background checks, to include name and fingerprint checks, that have not by the end of the next business day produced information rendering the applicant ineligible -

(A) be granted probationary benefits in the form of employment authorization pending final adjudication of the alien's application;

(B) may in the Secretary's discretion receive advance permission to re-enter the United States pursuant to existing regulations governing advance parole;

(C) may not be detained for immigration purposes, determined inadmissible or deportable, or removed pending final adjudication of the alien's application, unless the alien is determined to be ineligible for Z nonimmigrant status; and

(D) may not be considered an unauthorized alien (as defined in section 274A(h)(3) of the Immigration and Nationality Act (8 U.S.C. 1324a(h)(3))) unless employment authorization under subparagraph (A) is denied.

(2) Timing of Probationary Benefits."No probationary benefits shall be issued to an alien until the alien has passed all appropriate background checks or the end of the next business day, whichever is sooner.
Yes, you have read that right in 24 hours! In just one business day you have the full and complete backing of the ACLU and, no doubt, various lawyers working for such notables as the American Muslim Union, on your side!

Mind you, even if your papers don't pan out in the long run, the burden of proof is upon the government to 'show cause' why you should be deported, and as you have all the legal rights under the Constitution, you can then tie up the system for months or years in getting any prosecutions done. Show up at 5 pm one day, and 5 pm the next and every Local, State and Federal criminal database, plus database of known terrorists, plus checking out your actual documents to see if you actually are who you say you are, and the fingerprint database (has that finally been reconciled with the rest of the FBI's databases? I mean those folks spent 10 years trying to get a few databases to all operate together and billions of dollars and failed to do so. Twice.), verified your background fully and completely as can be done for someone coming from, most likely, a Nation with scanty computer resources, personnel and other capabilities....

The idea of background checks is that they are: lengthy, thorough and act as a screen BEFORE you give someone goodies to make sure they are who they say they are and are deserving of same. This system is based upon the supposition that they DO DESERVE THEM and that little effort can be put into actually *checking them out*. One is now in the exact position which Dafydd has posited: we cannot screen out bad actors because of the limitations of time placed upon such verification. And since so much falls upon the documentary evidence here, a bit later on, is the sweetened, condensed listing of what is acceptable: anything that establishes their presence, employment, or study, bank records, business records, employment records, labor union or day labor center, remittance records, sworn affidavits from nonrelatives who have direct knowledge of the alien's work, that contain (name, address, phone number, nature of relationship), or anything else the Secretary finds acceptable.

I call this aspect of it: the forger's full employment act.

If memory serves DHS and State had to weed out over 6 million incomplete, invalid, false or forged documents and try to verify a good number of them when looking at Visa applicants. That was *only* for Visa applicants, as Citizenship takes some time to go through the processing and weeds out its own bad papers. If the 7 million number for illegal aliens is correct, the absolute minimum number of pieces of bad paperwork to be checked out will be astronomical.

When I looked at the person-to-person banking and business systems that operate for money laundering, the number of connections to organized crime and terrorism are readily apparent. It is now possible wherever any of these informal systems operate to get bank, business, presence, employment, or, indeed, any of the records listed via the person-to-person contact system and have them delivered to you for a cash payment in your Nation of origin. Dafydd does believe that the TIA concept can actually *cover this*:
The reason it was so effective is that it was simply an object-oriented database data-matching application. It was not programmed with any pre-existing biases for one type of connection above the others; it noted and kept track of any and all connections between datapoints -- between Walid the terrorist and Guido the Mafioso, for example. Then it allowed for queries at any level of complexity.

The operators looked for connections where they would not expect to find any. Of course you could find a connection between the Secretary of State and various unsavory political leaders; that's the secretary's job. Nobody thinks Condoleezza Rice is in league with Bashar Assad simply because she met with him during a trip to Syria.

But suppose some dentist in Minneapolis calls Zarqawi in Iraq, then is called by a known terrorist in Pakistan, then is spotted by the FBI having lunch with an arms dealer in Minneapolis, then shows up as a co-signer on a loan to buy an airplane, when the other co-signer is a radical imam operating at a mosque out of Idaho.

Those connections are completely unexpected; why would one lousy dentist know all these people? In fact, that pattern is so suspicious that we should initiate surveillance to see what our "dentist" is up to.

But without TIA, the authorities would never have stumbled across the connections because they cross jurisdictional boundaries: The CIA identifies the terrorists abroad; the NSA records the calls; the FBI is tracking the arms dealer; and nobody is paying any attention to the imam. Without a single, unified database to bring all these observations together, nobody would notice the previously unknown dentist at the center of the web.

Now we take the TIA database... and we add to it the Parole Card and Z visa. Suppose we're looking for Walid Achmed Mohammed, a suspected jihadist who is thought to have sneaked into the United States in 2006 under an unknown alias. Today, we would have no idea where Walid could be found; because he is underground, he could be anywhere, under any name, working for anyone.

We make some educated guesses; let's suppose, just as Hugh fears, that Walid gets himself a Parole Card so he can move about and in and out.

CIA informants report that Walid was spotted at a "terrorism convention" in Pakistan in January of 2008; then another source believes Walid was at a training and planning session at a safehouse somewhere in Madrid in July. But that's all we know.

Under today's rules, that doesn't help us at all. But under the rules established by this bill, the very first thing we should do is query the TIA database to see which holders of Z visas traveled to Pakistan in January 2008 and to Madrid in July of 2008... I'd bet there were not that many. (Check not only direct routes but the roundabout routes that terrorists tend to use; the CIA is actually pretty good at that nowadays.)

Then you take that list of Social-Security numbers, winnow out the obvious non-targets, and plug that into the Z-visa employment database. This will tell you where the eight or nine potential "Walids" have worked in the past year. Since the real Walid has no reason to believe he has been outed, he will probably follow the same pattern... criss-crossing the country carrying messages and money and working for the same set of employers along the way.

By staking out each of those employers around the times he usually shows up, we suddenly have a very good plan for grabbing Walid Achmed Mohammed and hustling him off to Gitmo. And the best part is, neither he nor anybody in his cell would have the slightest idea how we did it!
I have some bad news for this lovely, object oriented system: when things are done at a distance with no record of intermediaries, you will, indeed start to stumble upon irregularities and you will have no idea what they mean. There is this lovely conception that data falls neatly together when it is properly tagged, entered and categorized. I have some bad news for anyone believing this on the Federal side: to cross the number of databases and their networks and security classification levels to do this is impossible.

The DoD, to get some better connectivity, spent 3 years to try and get from 7 different networks, each with their own classification and security constraints down to 5. The number of organizations involved included: NSA, CIA, DoD (Pentagon level), NRO, NGA, DISA, Dept. of State. When I last saw that project it was 2 years behind schedule, over budget and not working to segregate data streams like it should. That was some years back, but points to the Turf War problem and the inability of these actors to all play in the same sandbox.

To get this splendiferous TIA working, which was never Total in any way, shape or form nor designed to receive such large amounts of data but utilize clean data sets that had relatively rigorous metadata standards applied to them. To do *that* to this immigration bill will require all of the following to cooperate closely: DHS (including ICE, Border Patrol, and various other offices), FBI, Justice (Hoover building level, and no it isn't ALL FBI), IRS, HHS, CIA, NSA, DoD, DISA, State, Treasury, All of the State Criminal Databases, various international databases that the US has entree to via Treaty (like that Canadian one that put out bad information on an individual and the Canadian system was so CF'd that they could not even figure out if he was a citizen). Each of these groups comes with multiple databases, with multiple different and often non-agreeing metadata standards, each with their own sign-offs on who can and cannot use the system and at least 3 or 4 different and incompatible security classifications. Excuse me while I apply my background to this and state, definitively, that if you want this system up and working in less than 10 years, you are pipe dreaming.

We will have Quantum Computing before this massive database project gets *started*. People love to wave the magic wand of CIA around and make it out to be some splendid Agency that can work absolute miracles. They cannot even stop National Security leaks from their own Agency and the volume of those and number of operations and agents put at risk from those leaks makes a number of folks wonder exactly *who* they are working for. I would set the funding for this massive computer system in at around $3-5 billion, because of the amount of work and standardization that needs to go on up front before it can even be tested. This will require cross-working database standards, metadata standards, coming up with agreed upon internetworking capability, figuring out what the classification standards will be for the inflowing and outflowing data, finding out which networks need to get some inter-connectivity to them and working *those* issues, and that is before you even decide who can be allowed to have access to the actual, resultant data. That is the glory of object oriented databases: they like to know what the objects actually ARE and have good and clean definitions of them before you start. Meanwhile, for the next decade, you are stuck with multiple, incompatible databases, differing security standards, different computer networks and limited access to the resulting work product and all numbers of Agencies throwing hissy-fits that their turf is being invaded.

Mind you, a decade and $3-5 billion is OPTIMISTIC. I have personally seen more reported on other projects with higher amounts for less result in the recent past in the Federal Government because the lovely folks trying to put a neat and spiffy capability together do not understand the very basics of what it takes to actually get all of those lovely different parts of the government to work together. For something this size the Technical Working Group meeting will be at least 5-15 individuals from each of those groups I mentioned, including separate entourages for the sub-groups as they all are 'stakeholders' in the various systems and will have their work impacted by anything that fiddles with them. To get one relatively minor project going in one Agency, I have held working group meetings that consisted of over 30 individuals. And that was for a project that had high level blessing, which only means the back room knife fights are kept to a minimum.

We will get this splendid system that Dafydd posits the exact same day the HAL 9000 is put online.

Remember: each of those lovely documents needs some sort of tie-back, cross-check and such. These person-to-person banking and transaction systems have wide reach and scope, so the ability to find the disparate datapoints is damned difficult when someone from Syria contacts a peso exchange operator via a local hawala to get documents from, say, Denver, to show that someone has *lived there* and all you need are some relatively minor and obscure residency and employment records. These people are not *fools* who have been outwitting the FBI, CIA and other Federal Agencies for decades: they know how to leave a damned near impossible to find trail that leaves everyone looking legitimate and yet transacts and launders funds on a global basis.

This is before we even factor in the problem that Dafydd's 'Walid' can walk over to Mexico, jet out to Pakistan for a month, be spotted, come back, and have documents that PROVE he has been in the US all this time because he did not go through the border controls and picked up a different passport and visa for Pakistan from a contact on the other side of the border. By circumventing those lovely inputs, the CIA would *prove* that he was in Pakistan but have nowhere else to go because he had used the Transnational Terrorist and International Organized Crime internetworks to his advantage for cash advances, spending, visas, passports and such. And because he is utilizing the criminal side of things and getting false employment records for 'day labor' work that is minimal income it would be extremely difficult to demonstrate that he had *not* been here.

In this, even if the system works, the structural deficiencies of the actual, physical border and transport across it makes the entire concept irrelevent. In point of fact without physical barriers that are impassible and some way of checking for things like light aircraft and ultralights, there is *no way* to make individuals go through the actual ports of entry. And, because of Moore's Law, I will believe in a 'virtual wall' the exact same time that we get a 'virtual bathroom'. No real toilet paper allowed.

I place an actual, real, physical wall *with* sensors at around $5 billion and it would go up a damned sight faster than any data warehouse interconnection concept inside the Federal Government and have the great and good benefit of being armed, stopping illegal flights and having deep pilings to stop tunneling. If we had one of THOSE we could then have good, controlled ports of entry and actually consider this lovely data scheme, or just make enforceable and trackable Z-visas via it. But then if we had an actual, real, physical wall with deterrents of the lethal sort on them we would not have this problem in the first place now, would we?